- Post-Doc Researcher. PhD in Environmental Sciences both of Azores University, and Master degree in Integrated Managem... morePost-Doc Researcher. PhD in Environmental Sciences both of Azores University, and Master degree in Integrated Management of Marine Resources. Main research interests: transdisciplinarity, environmental economics, systemic approaches, social-ecological systems, participatory methodshttps://www.researchgate.net/profile/Maria_Guimaraes20edit
Check put the blog entrance at
https://i2insights.org/2018/05/29/transdisciplinary-research-context/
https://i2insights.org/2018/05/29/transdisciplinary-research-context/
Research Interests:
Transdisciplinarity is a demanding paradigm, considered by many in the literature as the way to move forward in terms of science and policy integration. In this paper we present the example of a tailored transdisciplinary (TD) process to... more
Transdisciplinarity is a demanding paradigm, considered by many in the literature as the way to move forward in terms of science and policy integration. In this paper we present the example of a tailored transdisciplinary (TD) process to tackle a key topic of European policy – the future of agriculture at the regional level. This phased process was followed in seven regions across Europe and involved the co-construction of future visions, engaging both researchers and a range of relevant stakeholders. This paper presents results based on a critical reflection made by researchers and stakeholders in Portugal and Scotland, throughout the participatory process. These results provide insights into the roles and responsibilities of researchers and stakeholders in TD processes. One main conclusion is that accumulated social capital can be essential to initiate and maintain a TD process, and requires a commitment between the research community and the surrounding society. Our analysis demonstrates the challenges of implementing a TD process within the temporal frame/boundaries of a research project and the added value of having transdisciplinarity as part of the long term strategy of a research group, not just one part of a specific project. Not acknowledging this may lead to disappointment and fatigue amongst those connecting with researchers. We also found that researchers position themselves differently in a TD process depending on their soft skills, experience and knowledge about transdisciplinarity; hence we call attention to the need to work more explicitly with these skills in the research environment and to present this concept in an early stage of researcher training, if better transdisciplinarity is to be achieved.
The number of cities experiencing population decline has been increasing worldwide. Despite the existence of theoretical propositions of shrinkage as an opportunity to increase levels of residential satisfaction, the issue has not been... more
The number of cities experiencing population decline has been increasing worldwide. Despite the existence of theoretical propositions of shrinkage as an opportunity to increase levels of residential satisfaction, the issue has not been addressed empirically. This article contributes to fill this gap by assessing, through survey, the residential satisfaction of inhabitants of four shrinking Portuguese cities. Data were analysed by means of a tree-decision approach: the Chi-squared Automatic Interaction Detection analysis. A sense of safety is the feature that best discriminates inhabitants' level of residential satisfaction. The results show that shrinkage due to deindustrialisation processes is detrimental to residential satisfaction.
Internet is an increasingly used tool opening a new era of communication. These opportunities are progressively adopted in SP studies. Little consideration has been given to its potential influence on sample composition and on how... more
Internet is an increasingly used tool opening a new era of communication. These opportunities are progressively adopted in SP studies. Little consideration has been given to its potential influence on sample composition and on how preferences are formed and stated. In Praia da Vitória bay, located in Terceira Island, in Azores archipelago, Choice Modeling was applied to understand birdwatchers preferences towards management options for bird watching sites. The survey included several challenges overcomed by choosing a mixed-mode surveying. Birders were questioned on-site using CAPI and off-site by phone/Skype assisted interviews. Respondents answered questionnaires by themselves in both cases. Birders identification, contact and pre-schedule were done using a mix of available tools, such as internet social networks, Facebook, birding forums and personal pages. In total 91 questionnaires were obtained, in a universe no bigger than 200 birders. Model estimations were performed taking into account total sample and the two subsamples: 1) on-site birders interviewed using CAPI; (2) off-site birders assisted by phone. Estimations were done with MNL and RPL models to check the influence of survey mode in preferences. No differences were found to survey mode which stresses the relevance of mixing-mode survey to respond to constraints imposed by the target population specificities.
Management of natural resources is a complex issue. Human history shows the need for sustainable management of natural resources and one of the premises for this is knowledge integration. Nevertheless the need to integrate different types... more
Management of natural resources is a complex issue. Human history shows the need for sustainable management of natural resources and one of the premises for this is knowledge integration. Nevertheless the need to integrate different types of knowledge poses a challenge. This paper proposes Conceptual Modeling as a tool to improve deliberation processes and research. Praia da Vitoria Bay in Terceira Island, part of Azores archipelago is the case study for Conceptual Modeling in a transdisciplinary setting towards system definition. During a three hour workshop, 18 stakeholders worked together to produce Conceptual Models describing Praia da Vitória Bay socio-ecological system. Participants included scientist of Azores University, local government with management responsibilities, private institutions that explore the area and local non-governmental institutions. The process, models obtained and stakeholder feedback are discussed. The exercise reveals that conceptual modeling is a challenging task for non-scientists. Nevertheless participants agree that this was a profitable moment of discussion and sharing visions, while cooperating to finalize the task. Information derived from the workshop includes not only variables and processes but, also scenarios. The overall result shows that during the 3 hour workshop data identification and integration has been achieved. The conclusion of this application is that collective Conceptual Modeling will not serve all purposes but, can be an important step towards integrated management.
When dealing with complex issues commonly found in Coastal Zones, there is a need to find an efficient assessment strategy of processes and their causes, as well as a method which could effectively promote a dialogue with the stakeholder... more
When dealing with complex issues commonly found in Coastal Zones, there is a need to find an efficient assessment strategy of processes and their causes, as well as a method which could effectively promote a dialogue with the stakeholder affected by these processes. This dialogues is an essential part of problem structuring routine since it allows mutual learning by generating and evaluating divergent knowledge claims and viewpoints. Problem structuring can start from a broad subject that is refined until the definition of a policy issue which requires a deeper analysis of its cause, as well, as possible alternatives of action. We explore the use of Q methodology as a tool for problem structuring and policy issue definition. In addition, Q methodology can be suitable for a first evaluation of the system in analysis while uncovering the several perspectives of stakeholders. We applied this methodology in Praia da Vitória Coastal System located in Terceira Island, in Azores Archipelago. The method has been applied in its original format as a method of identifying stakeholders discourse. Additionally we modified it and use it in group discussions aiming at promoting stakeholder dialogues. Results obtained show that Q methodology is an adequate to understand the value and interest of stakeholders, while adding useful information for stakeholder selection in stakeholder dialogues. The use of the method in its original format and in group session also allowed a reflection concerning the challenge of designing and promoting dialogue processes.
Tourism related to bathing has a growing economic importance in the Guadiana Estuary in southern Spain and Portugal. Polls of local public opinion showed an awareness of potential and current threats to the aquatic environment posed by... more
Tourism related to bathing has a growing economic importance in the Guadiana Estuary in southern Spain and Portugal. Polls of local public opinion showed an awareness of potential and current threats to the aquatic environment posed by regulation of river flow and untreated/poorly-treated urban sewage discharge. Because of this strong concern for water quality, it was selected as the policy issue for our application of the Systems Approach Framework (SAF). We developed an integrated simulation model of the Guadiana estuarine system in which the ecological system and socioeconomic components are linked by means of beach eco-label (Blue Flag Award) through its dependence on fecal bacterial thresholds. We quantified the socioeconomic impacts of water quality through an Economic Base Model that is used to portray the effect of increasing employment on resident population as a result of change in coastal water quality. A Cost-Benefit Analysis provides monetary indicators for scenario evaluation. It includes a monetary valuation of changes in water quality on human welfare using a Contingent Valuation Method. Because the population has a strong seasonal influence on the wastewater discharge into the estuary, we were able to simulate the feedback loop between the human activities that control water quality and those that benefit from it. We organized a critical evaluation of our efforts with the stakeholders, which allowed us to better understand their perceptions of the strengths, limitations, and opportunities for future SAF applications. Here we describe several aspects of our efforts that demonstrate the potential value of the SAF to environmental managers and stakeholders in clarifying some of the causal mechanisms, management options, and costs for resolution of the conflictual problem between water quality and tourism in the Guadiana estuary.
The definition of management actions in natural resource management requires the integration of all types of knowledge involved. An appropriate approach for such a challenge is the ideal of transdisciplinarity. A transdisciplinary process... more
The definition of management actions in natural resource management requires the integration of all types of knowledge involved. An appropriate approach for such a challenge is the ideal of transdisciplinarity. A transdisciplinary process can be considered " consultative " when knowledge is simply gathered and collated, or " participatory " when knowledge integration is undertaken collectively. In this paper, we present a mixed mode procedure (i.e., using interviews, questionnaires, and group discussions) that empirically demonstrates the difference between consultative and participatory transdisciplinary processes. The mixed mode procedure is used for identifying the most relevant problems occurring in the coastal system of Praia da Vit oria bay, Azores, Portugal. This mixed mode procedure is likely to be useful for other studies, because the results highlight the need to promote face-to-face interaction at the earliest opportunity, and because it allows an understanding to be gained of social learning processes, the influence of power, and participant behaviour during interaction with others.
Cities facing a continued and prolonged process of population decline require innovative urban regeneration policies complementary to growth-oriented policies. Losing inhabitants involves a decrease in economic activity and social... more
Cities facing a continued and prolonged process of population
decline require innovative urban regeneration policies
complementary to growth-oriented policies. Losing inhabitants
involves a decrease in economic activity and social capital.
Therefore citizens’ participation in defining policies to cope with
population decline is being increasingly advocated. This research
focused on four shrinking cities of Portugal to capture residents’
knowledge about the strengths and weaknesses of their city of
residence as well as the policies and actions they prioritized for
dealing with the population decline. The responses from 701
questionnaires show that economic revival policies as well as
safety and accessibility policies were preferred. To put these
policies into action, the recovery of industrial activity, the creation
of business incubators, an improvement in law enforcement, and
public lighting were ranked as top priorities. Rank-ordered logistic
regression models were used to understand which variables
influenced the residents’ rankings. We found that the evaluation
of the city’s characteristics impact the ranking of the policies and
actions. Hence, residents show a high level of coherence when
engaging in a discussion at the level of policy-making. Therefore,
the findings support residents’ involvement in decision-making
processes regarding urban regeneration in shrinking cities.
decline require innovative urban regeneration policies
complementary to growth-oriented policies. Losing inhabitants
involves a decrease in economic activity and social capital.
Therefore citizens’ participation in defining policies to cope with
population decline is being increasingly advocated. This research
focused on four shrinking cities of Portugal to capture residents’
knowledge about the strengths and weaknesses of their city of
residence as well as the policies and actions they prioritized for
dealing with the population decline. The responses from 701
questionnaires show that economic revival policies as well as
safety and accessibility policies were preferred. To put these
policies into action, the recovery of industrial activity, the creation
of business incubators, an improvement in law enforcement, and
public lighting were ranked as top priorities. Rank-ordered logistic
regression models were used to understand which variables
influenced the residents’ rankings. We found that the evaluation
of the city’s characteristics impact the ranking of the policies and
actions. Hence, residents show a high level of coherence when
engaging in a discussion at the level of policy-making. Therefore,
the findings support residents’ involvement in decision-making
processes regarding urban regeneration in shrinking cities.
The attractiveness of cities as places to live determines population movements into or out of them. Understanding the appealing features is fundamental to local governments, particularly for cities facing population decline. Pull and push... more
The attractiveness of cities as places to live determines population
movements into or out of them. Understanding the appealing
features is fundamental to local governments, particularly for
cities facing population decline. Pull and push attributes can
include economic aspects, the availability of amenities and
psychological constructs, initiating a discussion around which
factors are more relevant for migration. However, such discussion
has been underexplored in studies of shrinking cities. In the
present study, we contribute to the discussion by identifying pull
and push factors in Portuguese shrinking cities. Data were
collected using a face-to-face questionnaire of 701 residents in
four shrinking cities: Oporto, Barreiro, Peso da Régua and Moura.
Factor analysis and automatic linear modelling were used to
analyse the data. Our results show that the economic activity is
the most relevant feature for retaining residents. However,
characteristics specific to each city, related to heritage and natural
beauty, are also shown to influence a city’s attractiveness. The
cause of population shrinkage was also found to influence
residents’ assessments of the pull and push attributes of each city.
Furthermore, the results show the relevance of social ties and of
place attachment to inhabitants’ intention to continue living in
their city of residence.
movements into or out of them. Understanding the appealing
features is fundamental to local governments, particularly for
cities facing population decline. Pull and push attributes can
include economic aspects, the availability of amenities and
psychological constructs, initiating a discussion around which
factors are more relevant for migration. However, such discussion
has been underexplored in studies of shrinking cities. In the
present study, we contribute to the discussion by identifying pull
and push factors in Portuguese shrinking cities. Data were
collected using a face-to-face questionnaire of 701 residents in
four shrinking cities: Oporto, Barreiro, Peso da Régua and Moura.
Factor analysis and automatic linear modelling were used to
analyse the data. Our results show that the economic activity is
the most relevant feature for retaining residents. However,
characteristics specific to each city, related to heritage and natural
beauty, are also shown to influence a city’s attractiveness. The
cause of population shrinkage was also found to influence
residents’ assessments of the pull and push attributes of each city.
Furthermore, the results show the relevance of social ties and of
place attachment to inhabitants’ intention to continue living in
their city of residence.
It may seem paradoxical that in a period of rapid urban growth, some cities are shrinking; however, they are two sides of the same coin of urban change. This article identifies cities that are shrinking in Portugal. Looking at the... more
It may seem paradoxical that in a period of
rapid urban growth, some cities are shrinking;
however, they are two sides of the same coin of
urban change. This article identifies cities that
are shrinking in Portugal. Looking at the demographic
evolution from the 1991 until 2011 we
identified 17 cities that are losing inhabitants, 9
of them persistently and 8 since 2001. This
decline is present in the two biggest cities of
Portugal, Lisbon and Oporto that present 17%
and 21% decline respectively. After this first
screening, we crossed the history of each city
with socio-economic data (e.g. employment
rate, housing characteristics, and unemployment
among others) and purposed that reasons
for shrinking include: suburbanization, economic
transformation, satellite effect and environmental
drivers. However, several cities present
a mixture of reasons underlying shrinking
and further work should be undertake to complement
this exploratory analysis.
rapid urban growth, some cities are shrinking;
however, they are two sides of the same coin of
urban change. This article identifies cities that
are shrinking in Portugal. Looking at the demographic
evolution from the 1991 until 2011 we
identified 17 cities that are losing inhabitants, 9
of them persistently and 8 since 2001. This
decline is present in the two biggest cities of
Portugal, Lisbon and Oporto that present 17%
and 21% decline respectively. After this first
screening, we crossed the history of each city
with socio-economic data (e.g. employment
rate, housing characteristics, and unemployment
among others) and purposed that reasons
for shrinking include: suburbanization, economic
transformation, satellite effect and environmental
drivers. However, several cities present
a mixture of reasons underlying shrinking
and further work should be undertake to complement
this exploratory analysis.
